Toasting a Western Bagel? Here’s How To Get It Just Right

Western Bagels are soft, light, and chewy. So, when it comes to toasting, there’s a right way to do it. Let’s break it down:

Step 1: Start with a Fresh (or Properly Stored) Bagel

Whether your Western Bagel is fresh from the bag or has been living in the freezer, freshness matters. If frozen, thaw it for a few seconds in the microwave (about 10–15 seconds) before toasting. This keeps the inside soft and prevents uneven toasting.

Step 2: Slice with Care

Use a serrated knife and slice your bagel evenly. Uneven halves can lead to one side burning while the other side barely crisps. A bagel slicer is also a great tool to have.

Step 3: Set the Toaster Right

Set your toaster or toaster oven to medium—you want it golden, not scorched. If it’s your first time, test with one half to find your toaster’s sweet spot.

Optional: For a slightly crispier texture, use a toaster oven instead of a pop-up toaster. It provides more control and results in an even toast.

Step 4: Add a Finishing Touch

Once toasted, you can:

• Rub a little butter or garlic oil while it’s hot
• Spread on cream cheese or smashed avocado
• Pile on smoked salmon, tomatoes, or your favorite bagel toppings

The warmth of a well-toasted Western Bagel brings out the flavors like nothing else.

Pro Tip: Toast From Frozen the Right Way

Short on time? No problem. Just slice your Western Bagels before freezing. Then, pop the frozen halves directly into the toaster (set to medium-low) and toast for a bit longer—about 2.5 to 3 minutes. Boom, instant breakfast win.

With a bit of attention to detail, you can seriously upgrade your Western Bagel game. Treat it right, and it’ll give you that crispy-outside, soft-inside magic every time.

So next time you’re craving a toasted Western Bagel, you know exactly how to get it just right.