Free Shipping On Orders over $30 Hawaii and Alaska Are Excluded From Free Shipping. We Ship Mondays.

Free Shipping On Orders over $30 Hawaii and Alaska Are Excluded From Free Shipping. We Ship Mondays.

What to pair with a Pumpkin Bagel?

It’s pumpkin season, which means pumpkin bagels are available for a limited time at Western Bagel. Pumpkin bagels and pumpkin cream cheese can be purchased at any Western Bagel store! Pairing a pumpkin bagel with all the different sweet and cinnamon spice flavors can be tough. So, what do you pair with a pumpkin bagel?

At Western Bagel, you can eat a pumpkin bagel with various spreads and cream cheese flavors. Our number one recommendation is our house-made pumpkin cream cheese. Pumpkin cream cheese paired with a pumpkin bagel makes for the ultimate pumpkin spice and fall treat. Learn more about our pumpkin cream cheese here.

You can also enjoy a pumpkin bagel with Western Bagel’s classic cream cheese. Our classic cream cheese’s rich, creamy flavor will blend well with our pumpkin bagel’s warm, cinnamon-spice flavors.

Craving something sweeter? Spread jelly on a pumpkin bagel! A simple classic strawberry or grape jelly can add fresh fruity flavors to your pumpkin bagel. This bagel combo is best enjoyed open-faced.

Spread peanut butter on a pumpkin bagel for earthy, warm flavors. A smooth peanut butter spread is all you need for a nutty, cinnamon-spiced treat.

A pumpkin bagel with butter and a sprinkle of cinnamon on top is an excellent combo for a warm and woody delight.

Need to satisfy your sweet tooth? Add Western Bagel house-made strawberry cream cheese to your pumpkin bagel! The sweet strawberry flavor and bits of strawberry fruit will make for a tangy and sweet bagel with cream cheese.

You can purchase pumpkin bagels, pumpkin, classic, and strawberry cream cheese at any Western Bagel location. Locate your nearest one here.

Table Of Contents

Join our newsletter to stay up to date on deals and releases.
© 2025 Western Bagel. All rights reserved.

Please note that this login portal is specifically for our e-commerce website, and is not part of our mobile app and retail ordering system for our retail locations. If you are seeking to login to that portal instead, please follow this link.